Collecting Mathieson Woodworking Tools – A Practical Guide To Finding

ByJim Boslice Woodworking Tool

What are Mathieson tools? Mathieson tools are high-quality antique woodworking hand tools made by Alexander Mathieson & Son, a renowned Scottish toolmaker from the 19th and early 20th centuries. They are prized for their excellent steel, craftsmanship, and historical significance.

Why collect them? Collecting Mathieson tools offers a connection to woodworking history, access to superior-quality steel that holds a keen edge, and the satisfaction of restoring a functional piece of art. They are often more affordable than premium modern equivalents once restored.

Have you ever held an old hand plane and felt the weight of history in your hands? There’s a story in the worn tote, the darkened patina of the steel, and the faint maker’s mark that connects you directly to the craftsmen who came before us.

I promise that by the end of this guide, you’ll not only understand the appeal of collecting Mathieson woodworking tools but also have the confidence and knowledge to start your own collection. We’ll turn the intimidating world of antique tools into an exciting treasure hunt.

We’ll cover who Alexander Mathieson was, why his tools are so revered, what specific marks and models to look for, where to find them without overpaying, and how to bring these beautiful implements back to life. Let’s get started.

Who Was Alexander Mathieson & Son? The Legacy Behind the Tools

Before we dive into the “how-to,” it’s important to understand the “who.” Knowing the history adds immense value and appreciation to your collection. Alexander Mathieson & Son was a prolific and highly respected tool manufacturer based in Glasgow, Scotland.

Founded around 1822, the company operated for over a century, producing a massive range of tools for woodworkers, shipwrights, and other tradesmen. They were known for their innovation and, most importantly, their uncompromising quality.

Mathieson’s reputation was built on using high-quality cast steel for their blades and employing skilled craftsmen to produce tools that were both beautiful and incredibly functional. Their planes, saws, chisels, and braces were exported across the British Empire and beyond, which is why we can still find them today.

Why Start Collecting Mathieson Woodworking Tools? More Than Just Antiques

You might be wondering if it’s worth the effort. Why not just buy a new tool from the store? The benefits of collecting Mathieson woodworking tools go far beyond simply owning old objects. This is about building a user-friendly, high-performance toolkit with a soul.

  • Superior Quality Steel: Many argue that the crucible steel used in vintage tools like Mathieson’s is superior to that of many mid-range modern tools. It can take an exceptionally sharp edge and hold it longer, making for a more pleasant and precise woodworking experience.
  • Unbeatable Value: With a little patience and elbow grease, you can acquire a top-tier Mathieson hand plane or set of chisels for a fraction of the cost of a new premium equivalent from brands like Lie-Nielsen or Veritas.
  • A Tangible Connection to History: Using a tool that was handled by a craftsman 100 years ago is a unique feeling. It fosters a deeper appreciation for the craft and the generations who perfected it.
  • Sustainable Woodworking: This is the ultimate in eco-friendly collecting mathieson woodworking tools. You are rescuing a high-quality item from the scrap heap, reducing waste, and giving it a second, third, or even fourth life in your workshop.

Your Guide to Collecting Mathieson Woodworking Tools: What to Look For

Alright, let’s get to the fun part: the hunt. Knowing what you’re looking for is the most critical step. A successful search requires a keen eye for detail and an understanding of what makes a tool a treasure versus a piece of junk. This is your essential collecting mathieson woodworking tools guide.

Identifying Authentic Mathieson Markings

The first step is confirming you’ve actually found a Mathieson. The company used several marks over its long history, but the most common and recognizable is the “Star and Crescent” logo. Look for this stamped into the metal or wood.

Other common marks include:

  • “A. MATHIESON & SON”
  • “GLASGOW”
  • “SARACEN TOOL WORKS” (the name of their factory)

The presence of these marks, especially the Star and Crescent, is a strong indicator of authenticity. Be wary of faint or illegible stamps, as this can sometimes indicate a lesser-quality tool or a later, less desirable model.

Key Tools to Hunt For

While Mathieson made almost every tool imaginable, some are more desirable for modern woodworkers than others.

  1. Bench Planes: Look for their smoothing planes (similar to a Stanley No. 4), jack planes (No. 5), and jointer planes (No. 7 or 8). Their infill planes, with metal bodies filled with dense wood like rosewood, are highly sought after but often very expensive.
  2. Wooden Planes: Mathieson was a master of wooden-bodied planes. Moulding planes, plough planes, and dado planes are fantastic finds if the bodies are straight and free of major cracks.
  3. Chisels and Gouges: Their cast steel chisels are legendary. Look for tanged or socketed firmer, bevel-edge, and mortise chisels. Even if the handle is broken, the steel itself is worth saving.
  4. Braces: A Mathieson iron or wooden brace is a work of art. Check that the chuck mechanism still functions smoothly.

Assessing Condition: Beyond the Rust

Don’t be scared off by surface rust—it’s easily removed. What you need to look for are the deal-breakers. When you find a potential tool, perform this quick inspection:

  • Check for Cracks: Inspect the cast iron body of planes for hairline cracks, especially around the mouth and at the corners. A cracked body is usually not repairable.
  • Examine the Sole: Is the sole of the plane relatively flat? A slightly warped sole can be flattened (lapped), but a severely distorted one is a lot of work.
  • Look for Pitting: Light surface rust is fine. Deep, pitted rust, especially on the back of a chisel or the sole of a plane near the mouth, is a major red flag. It can make it impossible to get a flat surface and a sharp edge.
  • Assess Wooden Components: Check handles (totes) and knobs for cracks. Are they original? Replacements are available, but original, intact wood is always more valuable.

Where to Find Your Next Workshop Treasure

Now that you know what to look for, where do you go? Part of the joy is the search itself. Here are some of the best places to start your journey.

Online Marketplaces: Pros and Cons

Sites like eBay can be a goldmine, offering a worldwide selection. However, be cautious. You can’t physically inspect the tool, so rely on sellers with clear, high-resolution photos of all critical areas (sole, blade, maker’s mark). Ask questions if you’re unsure. Prices can also be higher due to competition.

The Thrill of the Hunt: Flea Markets and Estate Sales

This is where the real bargains are found. Get to flea markets, car boot sales, and farm auctions early. Dig through dusty boxes of old tools. Most sellers don’t know the difference between a high-quality Mathieson and a cheap hardware store brand, so you can often find gems for a few dollars.

Sustainable Collecting: Giving Old Tools New Life

Remember, every tool you buy this way is a win for the environment. You’re practicing sustainable collecting mathieson woodworking tools by preventing a perfectly usable, high-quality object from ending up in a landfill. You’re honoring the resources and energy that went into making it over a century ago.

Common Problems with Collecting Mathieson Woodworking Tools (And How to Solve Them)

Like any hobby, there are pitfalls to avoid. Being aware of these common problems with collecting mathieson woodworking tools will save you time, money, and frustration.

Overpaying for Common Models

Not every Mathieson tool is a rare artifact. Do a little research on eBay’s “sold” listings to get a feel for the market price of common bench planes or chisels before you buy. A standard No. 4 smoother, even in good condition, shouldn’t break the bank.

Mistaking Pitting for Patina

Patina is the beautiful, dark, aged surface that develops on old steel and is desirable. Pitting is active corrosion that eats away at the metal, leaving craters. Learn to tell the difference. A tool with deep pitting on a critical surface is a tool to leave behind.

The Dangers of Over-Restoration

Your goal is to make the tool usable, not to make it look brand new. Aggressive grinding, sanding away the maker’s marks, or slathering the wooden handles in polyurethane can destroy the tool’s historical and monetary value. Gentle and conservative restoration is always one of the collecting mathieson woodworking tools best practices.

The Mathieson Care Guide: Restoring and Maintaining Your Finds

You’ve found a tool! Now what? The restoration process is incredibly rewarding. This is your basic collecting mathieson woodworking tools care guide to bring your find back into service.

Gentle Cleaning and Rust Removal

Start by disassembling the tool completely. For rust, avoid harsh abrasives like grinders or sandpapers on critical surfaces. Instead, try one of these methods:

  • Evapo-Rust: A non-toxic, water-based rust remover that works wonders without damaging the underlying metal.
  • Electrolysis: A slightly more involved process using a battery charger and washing soda, but it’s extremely effective and safe for the tool.
  • Wire Brushes and Mineral Spirits: For light rust and grime, a good scrub with a brass brush (which won’t scratch the steel) and some mineral spirits is often enough.

Flattening Plane Soles and Sharpening Blades

The business end of the tool needs to be perfect. For a plane, this means lapping the sole flat. You can do this by using adhesive-backed sandpaper on a flat reference surface like a piece of thick plate glass or a granite tile. Work your way through the grits from about 120 up to 320 or 400.

The blade needs to be flattened on its back and then honed to a razor-sharp edge using sharpening stones (water stones, oil stones, or diamond plates) and a honing guide. A sharp Mathieson iron will sing through wood.

Treating and Protecting Wooden Handles

Clean the original wooden totes and knobs with mineral spirits and fine steel wool (#0000) to remove grime without stripping the original finish. Once clean and dry, apply a few coats of a penetrating oil finish like boiled linseed oil or a good paste wax to protect the wood and bring out its character.

Frequently Asked Questions About Collecting Mathieson Woodworking Tools

Are Mathieson tools better than modern tools?

They can be. A well-restored Mathieson plane or chisel will often outperform many mid-range modern tools due to the quality of its steel. They can perform on par with—and some collectors argue, better than—today’s most expensive premium brands.

How can I tell the age of a Mathieson tool?

Dating Mathieson tools precisely is difficult as their records are not as complete as a company like Stanley. However, the style of the logo, the type of wood used for handles (beech vs. rosewood), and specific design features can help experts place a tool within a certain era (e.g., mid-19th century vs. early 20th century).

Is it okay to use the tools I collect?

Absolutely! Most collectors believe the highest honor you can pay to a vintage tool is to put it back to work. Unless you have an exceptionally rare, mint-condition museum piece, these tools were made to be used. Sharpen it up and make some shavings!

The journey of collecting Mathieson woodworking tools is one of the most rewarding things you can do in this craft. You’ll learn about history, develop restoration skills, and build a set of tools that will not only serve you well but will carry stories for generations to come.

So get out there, keep your eyes open, and don’t be afraid of a little rust. Your next favorite tool is waiting to be discovered. Happy hunting, and stay safe in the workshop!

Jim Boslice
Latest posts by Jim Boslice (see all)

Similar Posts